Go Mobile

  • Bookmark the mobile version of First Draft HERE!

Donate

to First Draft

Tip Jar

Ads

Blogads

Ad Network

  • advertise_liberally

Paying the Bills

Blog powered by TypePad

« Oh Do Not EVEN, Squirrel Nuts | Main | Dollar Bill Jefferson Found Guilty »

August 05, 2009

Comments

Yes! Thank you Kirsten, thank you Chuck!

About 20 years ago (jeebus I'm getting old) I was home visiting, and at a dinner party, from the other end of the table, my Dad started in on what he thought was a hilarious story about a young lawyer he had hired who subsequently began to grow out his hair and wear earrings, and then makeup. Soon after, the young man approached my father, who was the firm's managing partner, about legally changing his name. He explained that he was transitioning from male to female.

My father's response? I was not in the room at the time, but I'm sure it was a short period of stunned silence and then a request for time to consult with the partners. Soon after, the young lawyer was asked to tender her resignation. And my Dad found all this very funny.

At the dinner party that night, I was the turd in the punchbowl who had the temerity to ask why this was funny. Granted, my Dad did grow up a very sheltered Catholic who even at age 50 had a very hard time believing all of the obvious signs that his law partner was screwing the help - that sort of thing just didn't happen in Dad's orbit. But I couldn't just laugh along with the rest. And I'm proud to say that my now Democratic Dad would probably react differently today.

But that we are two decades past that point and it is still necessary for transgendered and gay people to fight for their rights is enormously frustrating and disheartening.

We are moving in the right direction, but it will never be fast enough, because there will always be someone who gets left behind. It could be any one of us, given the limitless creativity of nature, and the the very limited minds of too many Americans. So please do as Virgo says: contact your reps and ask them to support ENDA.

And, while we're on the topic, a hearty congratulations (2 weeks late) to Diane Schroer, and kudos to Eric Holder for making the right call:

The US Department of Justice (DOJ) has decided not to appeal a federal district court ruling awarding transgender veteran Diane Schroer a total of $491,190 for the discrimination she suffered because of her sex after being refused a job with the Library of Congress...

Schroer had applied for a terrorism specialist position at the Library of Congress. Schroer was well-qualified for the job, having served in the US Armed Forces and having directed an organization that tracked and targeted international terrorist organizations. At the time she applied for the position, Schroer was undergoing the process to transition from male to female, but had not yet reached the stage of presenting herself as a woman. When she interviewed for the job, she used her legal, male name and presented herself to the decisionmaker with a male appearance. The Library of Congress offered her the job.

After the hiring paperwork had been submitted, but before she actually started work, Schroer told the decisionmaker that consistent with her treatment, she would present herself at work as a woman, change her name and begin dressing in traditionally female clothing. In part to allay any concerns the decisionmaker might have, she brought photographs of herself dressed as a woman. The next day, the decisionmaker withdrew the job offer, stating that Schroer would not be a "good fit" for the Library of Congress.
...
The record revealed that the decisionmaker who evaluated her did so based on sex stereotypes... The decisionmaker also stated that she had difficulty understanding the Schroer's decision to "transition" because of her prior Army and Special Forces background "as a particularly masculine kind of man."


I just don't get how an organisation dedicated to fighting discrimination would have a problem with this. Discrimination on any grounds apart from ability to do the job(and, preferably, get on with one's colleagues/clients) apart from being hateful, just makes no logical, economic or emotional sense...

Sadly, of course, having laws doesn't in and of itself stop employers behaving badly; but it's a start.

it's nice not have to worry because i know feingold will be there.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Contact Info

  • Adrastos
    adrastos at bellsouth.net
  • Athenae - Allison Hantschel
    athenae25 at yahoo.com
  • Jude
    jude_t at live.com

Athenae's Books

Paying The Bills

First Draft Krewe in NOLA


  • Click above image for our Hurricane Katrina coverage, including photos and stories from our recent First Draft New Orleans trip.

Lower 9th Ward: March 2006

  • 23
    These are stills captured from video shot March 2006 in the Lower 9th Ward of New Orleans specifically the area between N. Claiborne, Florida Ave, Tupelo and Tennessee.

Lower 9th Ward: August 2006

  • 9th_marking_side
    These are photos and stills captured from video taken August 2006 of the Lower 9th Ward specifically the area between N. Claiborne, Florida Ave, Tupelo and Tennessee.

Stats